Harbor View Hotel Edgartown, Edgartown

I had a wonderful experience at the Harbor View Hotel. The stunning harbor views from my room were absolutely breathtaking, and the dining at Bettini was a culinary delight with every meal exceeding expectations. The staff made me feel right at home, especially with their proactive assistance and engagement. However, the room rates can be on the higher side, which might be a consideration for budget-conscious travelers.

While the hotel has stunning harbor views, the recent experience was marred by some maintenance issues and a lack of prompt responses to concerns. The room's comfort was a highlight, but the overall value for money felt disappointing given the price tag. The dining experience was exceptional, and the outdoor spaces were enjoyable, adding to the appeal.

We had a lovely stay at this hotel, with beautiful renovations and a welcoming atmosphere. Our room was spacious and came with an awesome view, making our mornings enjoyable. However, we did encounter some noise from construction during our stay and faced inconveniences due to a wedding that impacted dinner availability. Overall, it's a great spot, but be aware of potential disruptions during peak times.

I had high hopes based on the hotel's reputation, but my experience was quite frustrating. While the Concierge, Darlene, offered exceptional service, the noise from ongoing construction was a real issue during my stay. The harbor views were gorgeous, but the service quality and dining experience, especially for the price, left much to be desired.

My stay at the Harbor View was absolutely fantastic, especially for celebrating my father's birthday and my sister's milestone. The service was unmatched, thanks to the amazing Tony Gatto, who made everything a breeze. The hotel offered breathtaking views, and the dining was top-notch—every dish was a delight. Although the overall experience was luxurious, the price point reflects that, making it feel like a treat for special occasions.